Major League Movers
Thursday, January 31st, 2008Moving sucks. Doesn’t it? Who wants to pack up all their stuff (or pay someone to do it) and have to lug it across town/state/country just to unpack it again? Of course, it rains, and of course, your friends don’t show up to help. Ugh.
In MLB though, moving teams or leagues can really affect the value a player has or is perceived to have. Its definitely a factor that is worth noting.
Miguel Cabrera (3B)Traded from the (NL) Marlins to (AL) Tigers. Could it be possible that his numbers could get any better? Why yes! Imagine what this young (he’s still only 25), power hitting, great batting average, RBI machine is going to do if he actually has other hitters around him.
Apologies to the Marlins, but Cabrera owners should be doing back-flips about this trade. If Miggy put up great numbers around the likes of the Marlins, wait until he’s in a lineup with Magglio, Pudge, Guillen, and Renteria. Not to mention Sheffield hitting instead of a pitcher every nine batters. This is the year he becomes a true superstar. 102-.325-42-125-2.
Miguel Tejada (SS) Traded from the (AL) Orioles to the (NL) Astros. DISCLAIMER: All of the following is to be disregarded if Tejada is not allowed back into the country! He will be, but I find that quite amusing. This is an interesting case to look at. The ballpark is a little better for power, but last year’s Orioles outscored the Astros by over 20 runs. Add to that the more than likely possibility that Tejada’s decline could continue. I could see the change of scenery helping, but I would expect the numbers to pretty much even out. 92-.302-22-94-1.
Johan Santana (SP) Traded from the (AL) Twins to the (NL) Mets. Wow. Still angry about this. He’s awesome. His team is easily my favorite to win the NL and he gets to face a pitcher every 9 batters. People are talking about injury concerns but until he gives you some real reason to worry continue worshiping at the Santana Shrine of Fantasy Studliness. 20W-.3.02-1.02-265K.
Scott Rolen (3B) Traded from the (NL) Cardinals to the (AL) Blue Jays. This trade was about one thing.
Getting Tony LaRussa and Scott Rolen the hell out of each other’s lives. I expect the change of scenery to help Rolen a great deal. He may not stay healthy because of that artifical turf, but if he does he will be so happy that it will show in his play. 88-.290-21-90-4.
Dontrelle Willis (SP) FA from (NL) Florida to (AL) Tigers. I’ve never really been a fan since he’s always been pretty inconsistent, but this move is only going to hurt him. He was already starting to fall apart but now he is in the hitting dominant AL. The topper is that even though Detroit is no hitter’s park, it’s still much more so than his former home. Bad news comin’. 10W, 4.55, 1.37, 150K.
I’m a believer. That ankle injury was something from which he just never recovered. He isn’t that old, and is still fast as hell. His BA was down, but not below acceptable levels and he stole bases when he could. Even with this crazy down year he was a source of steals at a thin position. If he can put up stats halfway ‘06 and ‘07 he will once again be an attractive option in your infield. 102-.284-10-52-39
That’s all I really need to know. If he cares and plays through (what have been perceived to be) minor injuries he could easily put up top 5 outfielder stats. 100-.315-38-125-1
Have you ever seen him when he gets fooled on an outside breaking pitch? I can’t believe that isn’t the only pitch he ever sees. Look for a some improvement over last year, but not enough to qualify as a rebound to former levels. 98-.255-32-100-3
SP- Now we get to the hardest part of fantasy baseball. Pitchers are so hard to predict from year to year that only the true cream of the crop are worth of top dollar. When you are paying for starters, it is important to remember that the reliability of health is just as, if not more, important as what they do when they are healthy. If anyone questions this, go ahead and draft Rich Harden for too much money just as I did last season and you will feel the pain (see also: Mark Prior). My top tier of starters is very very small. Santana, Peavy, Webb. Long gone are the days of Big Unit, Pedro, and Clemens being the studs. Now they don’t even fit into the second tier. This top tier have not only a track record of great ratios and Ks, but their health has been relatively good through their careers. They can carry a team in the ratios, making up for the terrible start you get from your 6th starter every other week. You will have to pay in order to get them, but go right ahead. You will see the bargain when pitchers with half the value go for 3/4 of the price. While wins are nice and can be predicted within a certain amount of error, it is not something that can be assured. Therefore, I give very little weight to wins totals from the previous year. The second tier is also very attractive, but it contains a lot of names that either haven’t broken through, haven’t put up great numbers for a couple straight years, have a history of injury, are getting old, or just aren’t quite at the level of greatness the first tier provides. Sabathia, Lackey, Bedard, Oswalt, Halladay, Beckett, Haren, Smoltz, C.Young, Hamels, Harang, C.Zambrano, Kazmir, and Dice-K. All are good prospects and most will serve well as the ace of your team. But they aren’t the safe, sure bet that the top three are. Rest assured that at least a couple of them will be as good as the top guys, but again, the risk of not doing so decreases the price you should be willing to pay. DO NOT PAY FOR THE UPSIDE OF THESE STARTERS. You will overpay in 90% of cases.
OF- Ah the outfield. So many players of quality. So many fakes too. It is sometimes hard to tell which of these guys are going to be the real deal and which are going to be baseball’s version of the Oneders. But we will just keep doin’ that thing we do, and trying to get the real deals. The top tier; Holliday, Crawford, Vlad, Ichiro, Soriano, Beltran, Lee, Sizemore, and Berkman. That may seem to be a pretty small top tier for a position with so many players, but that is really it. Furthermore, I would like to point out that of those guys, Vlad is slowing down some and his name is among the first tier only because he hasn’t dropped that far yet. His BA is awesome, his RBIs very good. But he made his name as a 40-40 threat with high BA. The sbs are all but gone, and the power seems to have lessened as well. There is a big difference in the price I would pay for a .320-40-40 guy and one that goes .320-27-2. Sorry Vlad, but you are now OVERRATED. The second tier is much larger with tons of upside. Surely several of those 2nd tier guys will join the first tier next season, but not being sure of which ones is what makes them less valuable and not worthy of the same price.
Man-Ram, Abreu, Magglio, Rios, V.Wells, Markakis, Granderson, Brynes, Hart, Andruw Jones, Pierre, Rios, and Hunter make up the second tier. Most of these guys are either getting old, too young to have established a top tier track record, or in the case of Pierre a specialist that only helps in a couple of categories. All are still valuable and worthy of protecting for the right price. They are not worth paying for as if their return to or joining of the first tier is assured. P.S. I did not put BJ Upton in this group because if you draft him here instead of in the IF, you are either stacked in the IF or are a moron.
2B- This seems to be a pretty deep position this year. The top tier goes by my count Utley, Phillips, and Brian Roberts. That is it. Even among those guys, there is no question that Utley is the most sought after commodity. While this is the case, his price is still based on upside. We are all still waiting for him to put it all together in the same season. The power, the huge average, the steals, and the RBI. His breakout ‘06 campaign was great, but there is more coming. Phillips has made great progress and rewarded his believers with a 30-30 season. At 2B that is HUGE!! Roberts offers another rare commodity, which is the potential for 50sbs at a thin(ish) position. That is tough to drop. In the second tier you find good players that are on the verge of putting up numbers that are first tier.
Robinson Cano, Dan Uggla, Ian Kinsler, and B.J. Upton. Imyself have a little man-crush on Ian Kinsler and have committed myself to protecting him for more than I would advise others to do so. Anyone one of these three could take that next step forward and reach the upper tier. In fact, I wouldn’t be surprised if any one of them or all four do this year. When it comes to these three guys, it is really going to come down to what price you have them for and what your team is lacking. I would not blame anyone for taking a gamble that their guy will step up.
Now don’t get me wrong. There are other guys that will put up great numbers and are certainly worth keeping. But if you are going to pay the same price for a 2nd tier guy at this position, you are out of your mind. A.Ramirez, Braun, Atkins, Figgins, Beltre, Zimmerman, C.Jones, and A.Gordon make up the second tier. Certainly, I’d want to hold on to most of these guys so long as I hadn’t paid a ton to get them last year. Braun might even be worth an extra couple bucks since he could turn out to be Pujolsian. But without any doubt, there will be one or two of these guys that disappoint. Jones could get hurt, Gordon could take a step back, or Figgins may lose some PT. The production of that top tier is not only a sure bet (barring injury), but the level of production is so high that I would find it impossible to drop any of them at almost any price.
Catcher- A thin position at the top, but after that a lot of the same. Martin and Martinezare really the only two no-brainers at this position. Having either one offers you a real advantage over the majority of the league which is thinking, “I’ll get two cheap catchers since they don’t really matter anyway.” Hey, they could be right. A smart GM could find two quality guys with upside for relatively little money. Catchers are beat on all year long, so it is true that it is a dangerous position to invest heavily in. But if you can get one of these two guys for a reasonable price they can pay real dividends. The next group at catcher can be tempting. Mauer, McCann, Posada have all been kept in the past, and all have the potential to render same kind of value that the top group does. I’ll tell ya, at least one of them will. The trick is not to pay the same price as you would have to in order to get Martin or Martinez. If you see the top tier as having a 90% chance of putting up the numbers you expect, then this group is closer to 75%. So pay accordingly. There are a bunch of sleepers that we will get into in later articles, but for keeper purposes, these are the guys that really matter.
There are certainly other guys that have the potential to join that group based on what they have done in the past, but these are the guys worth the big bucks. Big power with a high percentage chance to do what you think they will. Certainly, the second tier also can put up great numbers, and I’m sure that some of them will outshine some of the top tier in the coming year. I would not, however, pay the same for; Pena, Konerko, D.Lee, A. Gonzalez, or Delgado. Whether it is age, inconsistency, or injury problems, they all have significantly lesser chance to put up top tier stats. If you can keep them for cheap, then go right ahead. But if you paid for Konerko or Delgado based on their numbers when at their prime you should let them go and try to get them cheaper in the draft.
It is the day on which fantasy baseball publications are available to us all. Some are good, some are bad, but all give us little tidbits of information on players we have been anxious to learn about. Some new insight, some new projections, some new perspective which maybe we weren’t aware of. Each new year brings us a crop of new rookies to look at and a whole list of boom/bust type players that we will argue at length about with our competitors. Who are you protecting this year? Me? Well I wasn’t going to keep this guy, but hey, look what this magazine says about him!! Cheatsheets, rookie reports, rebounds, busts, breakouts, position battles, prospects, and lineups all available to us for the ever so cheap price of $6.99 a shot.